Practice 5 · answer: C
X = K (period 4, group 1) · Y = Na (period 3, group 1) · Z = P (period 3, group 15)
K vs Na, group 1: K adds a shell, larger · Na vs P, period 3: P's +15 grips the same shell tighter, smaller
largest to smallest: K > Na > P (answer C)
≈ 227 pm, 186 pm, 110 pm · sodium is the corner both comparisons pass through
A reversed both trends: down group 1 the new n = 4 shell makes K the larger of K and Na, and across period 3 P's +15 draws the same shell in, so P is the smallest; Z > Y > X is the correct list read backwards. B ran the group trend backwards: K sits a row below Na and opens a new shell, so K is the larger. D let Z's stronger nucleus push electrons out: a stronger pull draws the same shell inward, so P is the smallest.
Decode each configuration to its square on the table, then compare through the shared corner: down adds a shell, right tightens the grip. ✓